The unforgiven: Football’s most controversial transfers
Football fans can forgive a missed penalty. They can even forgive a bad season. But joining the wrong club? That can be a different story altogether. Some transfers have turned heroes into villains overnight and created rivalries that lasted long after the player left.
From Sol Campbell's sensational move from Tottenham Hotspur to Arsenal to Luis Figo's infamous switch from Barcelona to Real Madrid, football history is packed with transfers that crossed lines supporters believed should never be crossed.
Sol Campbell: Tottenham to Arsenal (2001)
Few transfers in English football have caused more fury than Sol Campbell's move from Tottenham to Arsenal in 2001. Campbell had come through Tottenham's academy, made more than 300 appearances for the club, captained Spurs and lifted the League Cup in 1999. At 26, he left when his contract expired.
The reaction was extraordinary. Tottenham fans displayed 'Judas' banners when Campbell returned to White Hart Lane, threw bottles and hung an effigy of the former captain from a lamppost on Tottenham High Road. Arsenal manager Arsene Wenger later admitted he was not sure he would sign Campbell again, knowing the abuse he would face. The decision worked on the pitch, however, with Campbell winning two Premier League titles and three FA Cups.
Luis Figo: Barcelona to Real Madrid (2000)
If Campbell's move shocked England, Luis Figo's transfer from Barcelona to Real Madrid sent shockwaves through Spain. Figo joined Madrid for a then-world-record £37 million after winning La Liga with Barcelona in 1998 and 1999.
The Portuguese winger had been one of Barcelona's biggest stars. Moving directly to their fiercest rivals was viewed as the ultimate betrayal. When Figo returned to Camp Nou in a Real Madrid shirt, the reception was ferocious. Objects were thrown at him whenever he approached the corner flag, forcing the match to be interrupted. Two years later, a pig's head was infamously thrown onto the pitch.
Mo Johnston: Celtic to Rangers (1989)
Few transfers carry the historical weight of Mo Johnston's move from Celtic to Rangers in 1989. The Glasgow rivalry encompasses far more than football, and Rangers had an unwritten policy against signing Catholic players. That changed when Johnston, a former Celtic striker, joined from French club Nantes.
The transfer was hugely controversial and broke one of Scottish football's most deeply rooted traditions. Johnston's agent, Bill McMurdo, later said that after the signing, he and his client required 24-hour security.
Roberto Baggio: Fiorentina to Juventus (1990)
When Fiorentina sold their talisman to bitter rivals Juventus for a world-record transfer fee, it sparked riots in the streets of Florence, resulting in injuries and arrests. The animosity between the two clubs was already intense, and losing their star player proved to be the final straw for some Fiorentina supporters.
The drama spilled onto the pitch when the two sides met. Baggio famously refused to take a penalty against Fiorentina and was subsequently substituted. As he walked off, he picked up a Fiorentina scarf thrown onto the pitch and wrapped it around his neck, creating one of football's enduring images of transfer drama.
Gonzalo Higuain: Napoli to Juventus (2016)
If any modern transfer rivals the chaos of Baggio's move, it is Higuain's. The Argentine striker had just broken the Serie A single-season scoring record with Napoli, achieving god-like status in Naples. Then, Juventus triggered his €90 million release clause.
The backlash was visceral. Napoli fans took to the streets, burning his effigy, flushing his replica jerseys down toilets, and famously attaching pictures of his face to the city's garbage trucks. He had gone from the king of Naples to public enemy number one overnight.
Eric Cantona: Leeds United to Manchester United (1992)
Cantona's move was seismic in terms of historical impact. Leeds had just won the First Division title, only to sell their enigmatic French forward to Manchester United for £1.2 million months later.
The transfer became a turning point in English football. Cantona was the final piece of Sir Alex Ferguson's puzzle as United went on to dominate the Premier League era, leaving Leeds supporters to watch one of their former players become central to their rivals' success.
Alan Smith: Leeds United to Manchester United (2004)
Alan Smith's move from Leeds United to Manchester United carried enormous emotional weight. Smith had come through Leeds' academy and become one of the club's most recognisable players.
When Leeds were relegated from the Premier League amid financial turmoil, Smith moved directly to Old Trafford. The rivalry between Leeds and United goes far beyond football, making his decision particularly difficult for his former supporters to accept. A player who had represented Leeds' identity was suddenly wearing the shirt of the club they despised most.
Carlos Tevez: Manchester United to Manchester City (2009)
Carlos Tevez's move added another fiery chapter to the Manchester rivalry. Tevez had spent two seasons at United on loan from West Ham, winning two Premier League titles. United wanted to sign him permanently, but the Argentine instead opted to join City.
City were still building towards the dominance that would later define them, and they used the transfer to make a statement. A huge blue billboard appeared in Manchester with the message: 'Welcome to Manchester.' Sir Alex Ferguson called the stunt “stupid and arrogant”. The transfer had already been controversial, but the billboard made it intensely personal.
Emmanuel Adebayor: Arsenal to Manchester City (2009)
Adebayor's move followed a similar pattern to Tevez's, with City using their newfound wealth to recruit established talent. But what cemented the transfer's place in Premier League folklore was the immediate aftermath.
For all latest news, follow The Daily Star's Google News channel. 
When City played Arsenal weeks later, Adebayor scored and then sprinted the length of the pitch before sliding on his knees in front of the travelling Arsenal supporters. Objects were thrown from the stands, creating one of the most infamous celebrations in Premier League history.
Ashley Cole: Arsenal to Chelsea (2006)
The saga that coined the nickname "Cashley" remains one of London's most bitter transfers. Cole was an Arsenal academy graduate and a key member of the 'Invincibles,' but the relationship soured dramatically over contract negotiations.
He famously claimed in his autobiography that he nearly swerved his car off the road when Arsenal offered him £55,000 a week. His subsequent move across London to Jose Mourinho's newly affluent Chelsea infuriated Arsenal fans and defined the intense rivalry between the two clubs for a generation.
Robin van Persie: Arsenal to Manchester United (2012)
Robin van Persie's move from Arsenal to Manchester United left many Arsenal supporters feeling betrayed. The Dutchman had become Arsenal captain and one of the Premier League's leading strikers, but after years without a league title, he decided to leave north London for Old Trafford.
Van Persie won the Premier League in his first season with United and finished as the competition's top scorer. For Arsenal fans, seeing their former captain help one of their biggest rivals win the title made his departure particularly painful.
Fernando Torres: Liverpool to Chelsea (2011)
Liverpool supporters were left utterly blindsided when their star striker handed in a sudden transfer request on the final days of the January window. Chelsea secured the Spaniard for a then-British record £50 million, instantly turning an Anfield icon into a villain.
Devastated fans burned his number nine shirt in the streets outside the stadium. While Torres went on to win the Champions League in London, the abrupt nature of his departure to a direct Premier League rival left a scar that took years to heal.
Mario Gotze: Borussia Dortmund to Bayern Munich (2013)
Gotze was the golden boy of Jurgen Klopp's thrilling Dortmund side. The announcement that Bayern Munich had triggered his release clause came shortly before Dortmund's Champions League semi-final against Real Madrid.
The timing caused uproar among Dortmund supporters, particularly with the two German giants set to meet in the Champions League final at Wembley just weeks later. Gotze's move to Bayern became another example of the Bavarian club taking a leading player from one of its domestic rivals.
Johan Cruyff: Ajax to Feyenoord (1983)
Sometimes a controversial transfer is driven by pure spite. Johan Cruyff is synonymous with Ajax, but in 1983, the Amsterdam club refused to offer their 36-year-old legend a new contract, assuming his best days were behind him.
Furious at the perceived disrespect, Cruyff signed for their most bitter rivals, Feyenoord. The ultimate revenge mission was a complete success: Cruyff played a starring role as Feyenoord won a league and cup double, proving his former employers spectacularly wrong while wearing the shirt of their greatest enemy.
The next controversial move?
Cristian Romero could potentially add another chapter to the list. The Tottenham captain has been linked with interest from Arsenal, although Spurs would be highly unlikely to welcome an approach from their north London rivals, let alone sanction a move.
If Romero were ever to swap Tottenham for Arsenal, he would be following a path made infamous by Campbell.
And that is the strange thing about football's biggest rivalries. Players can leave for better contracts, bigger trophies or new challenges. But when they cross certain lines, supporters do not always see a transfer.
They see a betrayal.
Comments